इंडियन आवाज़     30 Nov 2023 03:22:57      انڈین آواز

SC asks Govt to strike balance between national interest and Rohingya issue


Our Correspondent / New Delhi

The Supreme Court today asked the government of India to strike a balance between the national security, economic interest and the humanitarian consideration involving the Rohingya women, Children, old, sick and infirm.

“We have to strike a balance between national security and economic interests and humanitarian considerations” involving Rohingyas, said Chief Justice Dipak Misra heading the bench also including Justice A.M.Khanwilkar and Justice D.Y.Chandrachud.

Chief Justice Misra said, “How we reconcile the national security and economic interests and protection of women, children, old, infirm, sick and innocents” Rohingyas and “How far this court can go.”

Having said this, Chief Justice Misra said, “As a constitutional Court of this country we can’t be oblivious of this and simultaneously the executive too can’t be oblivious of this.”

The Apex court said this as Centre resisted its earlier observation that the government can take action involving Rohingyas where it is necessary but you will not deport them.

“You can take action where it is necessary, you will not deport them”, the bench said. Additional Solicitor General Tushar Mehta urged told the court not to pass any such order as it would a international ramifications.

In an attempt to persuade the court not to pass such an order, Mehta said, “Where there are international obligations we know our responsibility.”

UN launches aid appeal for Rohingya refugees

The court today also clarified that Article 21 guaranteeing right to life and liberty was not available to the citizens alone but all those living in India.

Article 21 says that guarantees the protection of life and liberty says e” No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.”

The court’s observation assumes significance as Centre has questioned the maintainability of the petition by the two Rohingya refugees contending that they can’t invoke the jurisdiction of the top court under Article 32 seeking the protection of their right to life and liberty.

As court fixed November 21 for the hearing of the matter for two days, the court permitted amicus curiae Fali Nariman to approach the court in the case of any contingency.

Nariman who said that he was only concerted the human rights told the Centre , “My stand is human rights”.

In his submission Nariman said that the Foreigners Act that provides for the identification and deportation of illegal foreign national there are exception for case of Hindus, Parsees, Budhists, and the Sikhs.

Nariman said that the exceptions under the Foreigners Act should be extended to Rohingya Muslims and Rohingya Hindus.

The court permitted liberty to Nariman to knock its door in the face of contingency as ASG Mehta objected to court saying that the matter is sub-judice.

Mehta was discomforted when court earlier while directing the next hearing on November 21, had said, “Needless to say that the matter is sub-judice”.

He urged the court not to pass any such order as it would have an international ramifications.

The top court was initially moved by one Mohammad Salimullah and another Rohingya refugee seeking top court’s intervention to stop Centre’s moves to deport them.

However, later top court was moved by others supporting government’s stand on deporting them.

Rohingya petitioner Mohammad Salimullah has told the court that they were not illegal immigrants but were refugees who fled Myanmar and came to India for shelter in the wake of their persecution on the grounds of their religion and community identity. They have contended that they were entitled to all protection under the international conventions on refugees and treaties.

On the other hand Centre has asked not to interfere with its policy decision to deport Rohingyas as it alleged that some of them had links with Pakistan and Bangladesh based terror outfits.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


حکومت نے غریب کلیان ان یوجنا کو یکم جنوری 2024 سے مزید پانچ سال کی مدت کیلئے بڑھا دیا ہے۔

@PIB_India حکومت نے پردھان منتری غریب کلیان ان یوجنا کو یکم جنو ...

اتراکھنڈ: سرنگ میں پھنسے 41 مزدوروں کو بحفاظت باہر نکال لیا گیا۔: UTTRAKHAND TUNNEL

اترکاشی ٹنل حادثے میں 17ویں دن ایک بڑی کامیابی ملی ہے۔ بالآخر ...

پاکستان چھوڑنے پر مجبور افغان مہاجرین Pakistan-Afghanistan

اقوام متحدہ کے عالمی پروگرام برائے خوراک (ڈبلیو ایف پی) نے کہ ...


Thailand announces visa-free entry for Indian citizens

Thailand is scrapping visas for scores of Indian tourists in order to rekindle the fire in its tourism sector. ...

World Tourism Day 2023: Govt Launches ‘Travel for LiFE’ Campaign

By Vinit Wahi On the occasion of World Tourism Day 2023 today, the Ministry of Tourism (Northern Region) u ...

Santiniketan inscribed on UNESCO World Heritage List

AMN / WEB DESK Santiniketan, the famed place where great poet Rabindranath Tagore built Visva-Bharati over ...


International forum on ‘Role of Media in Inciting Hatred and Violence’ begins in Jeddah

JEDDAH The Secretary-General of the Muslim World League Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulkarim Al-Issa on Sunday hi ...

Journalists felicitated on National Press Day at Press Club of India

Journalists will have to fight together against attacks on press freedom: Siddharth Varadarajan Staff R ...


India and US to launch joint microwave remote sensing satellite (NISAR) for Earth observation

India and the US will launch the joint microwave remote sensing satellite for Earth observation in the coming ...

Vikram Sarabhai Space Research Center plays crucial role in field of space: Jitendra Singh

AMN / WEB DESK Union Minister of State Jitendra Singh said that Vikram Sarabhai Space Research Center( VSSC ...

@Powered By: Logicsart