India reports 11.8% jumps in cyber crime in 2020: NCRB data
India, US have similar goals, share same zeal towards climate change: Power Minister
Sitharaman announces govt guarantee worth Rs 30,600 cr for ‘bad bank’
Govt says, COVID weekly positivity rate for last 11 weeks is below 3%

इंडियन आवाज़     19 Sep 2021 05:38:07      انڈین آواز

Supreme Court finds RTI replies unreliable


It refers to the news-item (Bar and Bench 09.07.2021) that a Supreme Court bench made an observation on 09.07.2021 that RTI replies are not very reliable. Observation was not only generic but even was crucial in the case before the Bench. If even the Apex Court has such an observation, then there is no logic in continuing with spending so much on carrying on with the transparency Act legislated in the year 2005 which became instrumental in exposing big scams like CWG-2010, coal-block and spectrum allocation. Supreme Court observations will make High Courts and lower courts also declining to accept RTI replies as evidence in court-cases. It would have been better if Supreme Court judges making such observation out of their own experiences would have mentioned their such experiences in their verdict directing authorities to take action against the concerned ones in public-authorities for giving unreliable RTI replies.

However it is a fact that improper replies are given under RTI Act. At times, information exempted under section 8 of RTI Act is also provided also defying Apex Court orders, just before the matter reaches Central Information Commission (CIC) out of fear of being penalised by CIC. Misuse of RTI Act for publicity-seeking, black-mailing and yellow-journalism is increasing day-by-day which needs proper training and consultancy in public-authorities apart from tightening RTI rules which includes making RTI fees uniform for all public-authorities at rupees 50 with cost of first 20 copied pages included in basic suggested fees of rupees 50 with no further fees charged at level of First and Second Appeals, and making it compulsory to enclose copy of Identity Proof with each RTI application, First and Second Appeals in accordance with verdict of Punjab and Haryana High Court dated 02.11.2012 by Punjab and Haryana High Court in the matter -Fruit and Merchant Union vs Unknown (CWP No. 4787 of 2011)- (page 23).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Delhi Capitals’ ultimate goal is to win the IPL; Captain Rishabh Pant

By Harpal Singh Bedi New Delhi, 18 September: Delhi Capitals' Captain Rishabh Pant, says his team's ultimat ...

​Raninder Singh Reelected President of the National Rifle Association of India

Harpal Singh Bedi New Delhi, 18 September: In a straight contest incumbent Raninder Singh defeated&nbs ...

Error-free rounds enable Honey Baisoya, Khalin Joshi to take joint halfway lead at J&K Open

Harpal Singh Bedi Srinagar, 16 September Delhi golfer Honey Baisoya and Bengaluru’s Khalin Joshi returned ...


اکاؤنٹ ایگریگیٹر – آپ کی مالیاتی زندگی کو کیسے آسان بنا سکتا ہے

عندلیب اخترگزشتہ ہفتے مرکزی حکومت نے ایک نئے مالیاتی ڈیٹا شی ...

اقوام متحدہ کے سربراہ کی اس عالمی ادارے کی فعالیت بہتر بنانے کے لیے تجاویز

اقوام متحدہ کے سیکرٹری جنرل انٹونیو گوٹیرش نے اس عالمی ادارے ...

نائن الیون9/11 کی بیسویں برسی: بائیڈن کی جانب سے اتحاد کی اپیل

WEB DESK امریکی صدر جو بائیڈن نے نیو یارک کے ٹوئن ٹاورز پر حملو ...


Google Doodle Honours Poet, Freedom Fighter Subhadra Kumari Chauhan

WEB DESKOn the occasion of the Indian activist and author's 117th birth anniversary,Google Doodle on Monday, 1 ...

Kerala Governor appeals jewellers to refrain from using photographs of brides to further their sales

AMN Kerala Governor Arif Mohammed Khan today appealed to jewellers to refrain from using the photographs of ...

@Powered By: Logicsart

The Indian Awaaz