Last Updated on November 22, 2026 7:15 pm by INDIAN AWAAZ

R. Suryamurthy

India’s economic expansion is increasingly being sustained by a narrow set of high-performing sectors, raising questions about the durability and inclusiveness of a recovery that continues to look impressive in aggregate. Manufacturing and financial services are providing considerable support, but agricultural weakness, rising inflation, a moderation in government spending and renewed geopolitical risks are exposing vulnerabilities that could become more pronounced in the second half of 2026-27.

The National Statistical Office (NSO) is scheduled to release its provisional estimates for the July-September quarter on November 30. Economists expect gross domestic product (GDP) growth to remain between 7.4% and 7.8%, marginally below the 7.8% recorded in the preceding quarter. ICRA forecasts 7.5%, Bank of Baroda 7.4%-7.5%, while Bank of America, DBS Bank and HDFC Bank anticipate growth of around 7.7%. SBI Research projects 7.8%, compared with the Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI) estimate of 7.2%.

The immediate question is whether the economy can maintain this pace. The more important one is whether the expansion has acquired sufficient breadth to withstand a combination of weakening rural demand, higher production costs and diminishing fiscal support.

Manufacturing currently offers the strongest evidence of industrial resilience. Output expanded 8.1% in the second quarter, accelerating from 6.9% in the first, with automobiles, electrical equipment, transport equipment and petroleum products accounting for much of the improvement. Motor vehicle production increased 22.7%, while electrical equipment output surged 31.8%.

ICRA estimates manufacturing gross value added (GVA) growth at 8.2%, while Bank of Baroda expects 9.5%. Improved corporate revenues and a recovery in profitability among listed manufacturers reinforce the impression that industrial activity has retained considerable momentum despite supply-chain disruptions and geopolitical uncertainty.

But production growth should not automatically be interpreted as evidence of a durable investment revival. The critical test is whether companies see sufficient final demand to commit fresh capital, expand capacity and undertake long-term projects. Higher output without corresponding improvements in demand could eventually create pressure on margins and discourage investment.

Services continue to provide the larger contribution to economic expansion, although their performance is becoming less uniform. ICRA expects services GVA to grow 9.1%, against 10% in the previous quarter, while Bank of Baroda projects 8.2%. Financial, real estate and professional services remain relatively strong, supported by credit expansion of 19.8% and deposit growth of 17.5%, according to Bank of Baroda.

The picture is less reassuring in trade, hotels and transportation. Higher fuel costs and geopolitical disruptions have affected operating conditions, while the services purchasing managers’ index averaged 54.2 in the second quarter, compared with 61.4 a year earlier.

This divergence has implications beyond sectoral growth rates. Financial services can generate substantial value addition without necessarily producing employment on the scale required by a labour-intensive economy. Trade, hospitality, transportation and other consumer-facing activities have a more direct relationship with household incomes and employment. Their relative weakness suggests that the benefits of expansion may not be spreading evenly across the economy.

Consumption, nevertheless, remains an important source of support. Vehicle sales, electricity demand, goods and services tax collections, e-way bill generation and bank lending indicate that domestic economic activity has not lost its underlying momentum. Festive spending has also helped sustain demand.

However, aggregate consumption indicators can obscure differences between households. Urban demand, supported by formal employment and access to credit, may remain relatively resilient even as rural purchasing power comes under pressure. Agriculture is therefore emerging as a potential fault line in an otherwise favourable growth narrative.

ICRA estimates agricultural GVA growth at just 0.2% in the second quarter, compared with 3.6% in the first. Bank of Baroda is more optimistic, projecting 2.8%, although that would still represent a moderation from 5.1% a year earlier.

The underlying agricultural indicators offer little reason for complacency. The southwest monsoon was 12.6% below the long-period average, according to Bank of Baroda. Reservoir levels stood at 63.3% on November 12, against 90% a year earlier. Kharif sowing declined 1%, with rice acreage contracting 3.5%, according to ICRA.

The economic consequences could be considerably wider than the immediate contribution of agriculture to GDP. Farm incomes influence demand for two-wheelers, consumer durables, packaged goods and a range of services across smaller towns and rural markets. A prolonged deterioration in agricultural conditions would consequently affect manufacturers and retailers that currently benefit from relatively strong urban demand.

The possibility of El Niño conditions persisting adds another layer of uncertainty, particularly if rainfall deficiencies translate into lower agricultural output and incomes in subsequent quarters.

Inflation, however, may prove to be the more immediate constraint on economic policy. Retail inflation climbed to 6.09% in October, exceeding the RBI’s upper tolerance threshold of 6%, with food inflation reaching approximately 8.9%. Wholesale price inflation increased to 12.29% from 11.39% in September, reflecting substantial pressure from fuel and power prices.

These developments complicate the conventional argument that strong economic growth provides sufficient room for monetary policy to remain supportive. Inflation is not merely a statistical problem for the central bank. It redistributes purchasing power, particularly away from households with limited capacity to absorb higher food, transport and electricity expenses.

At the same time, rising energy and input costs increase the operating expenses of manufacturers, transport companies and service providers. Businesses must choose between accepting lower margins and transferring additional costs to consumers. Either response carries economic consequences: the former weakens profitability and investment capacity, while the latter risks further suppressing consumption.

The RBI consequently faces a difficult balancing act. If inflation proves persistent, the scope for monetary easing could narrow, keeping borrowing costs elevated for households and businesses. Yet tighter financial conditions could weaken precisely the consumption and investment demand that policymakers need to sustain growth.

The distributional consequences of this dilemma deserve greater attention. A monetary response directed at aggregate inflation cannot, by itself, resolve supply-side pressures arising from food shortages or higher energy costs. Excessively restrictive conditions could impose additional costs on businesses and households that have contributed little to the original inflationary pressures.

Fiscal policy is facing its own constraints. Public investment has been a central pillar of India’s recovery, supporting infrastructure construction, capital goods, transportation and industrial demand. Any sustained moderation in government expenditure could therefore have consequences extending well beyond the public sector.

ICRA estimates that central government capital expenditure growth slowed to 2.8% in the second quarter from 23.7% in the first. Non-interest revenue expenditure contracted 0.8%, following growth of 19.5% in the preceding quarter.

Bank of Baroda presents a somewhat more favourable picture, estimating cumulative central government capital expenditure growth at 12.7% during April-September. Nevertheless, the quarterly slowdown suggests that the fiscal contribution to growth may be becoming less powerful.

The issue is whether private investment is sufficiently established to take over as the principal driver of capital formation. Manufacturing growth and improved corporate profitability are encouraging, but companies will need confidence in sustained demand, predictable input costs and stable financing conditions before committing to large investment programmes. A premature withdrawal of public investment could weaken the demand conditions necessary for private capital expenditure to accelerate.

External developments offer both relief and risk. The temporary cessation of hostilities between the United States and Iran has eased pressure on international crude markets. Bank of Baroda estimates that oil prices declined from approximately $118 a barrel on October 30 to $91.50 on November 10.

For an economy heavily dependent on imported energy, a sustained decline would provide considerable macroeconomic relief. It would reduce the import bill, ease inflationary pressure, improve the external balance and lower costs for energy-intensive industries. Bank of Baroda estimates that a sustained 10% reduction in crude prices could lower India’s import bill by $9 billion-$10 billion.

But the geopolitical situation remains unsettled. A renewed escalation could reverse the improvement in energy prices, placing fresh pressure on the rupee, inflation and the government’s fiscal calculations. India’s growth outlook is therefore exposed to developments beyond the control of domestic policymakers.

The forecasts for the full financial year reflect these competing forces. ICRA expects GDP growth of 7.1% in FY27, citing agricultural weakness, inflation, elevated input costs and the high base associated with GST rate rationalisation. Bank of Baroda projects 7.2%, with an upward bias if international oil prices remain favourable.

ICRA Chief Economist Aditi Nayar has cautioned that growth could moderate in the second half as these pressures accumulate. October indicators provide some reassurance: the services PMI improved to 55.8 from 55.2 in September, while credit, deposits, diesel consumption and port cargo traffic remained supportive.

Yet isolated improvements in monthly indicators should not distract from the structural question confronting the economy. India’s ability to sustain growth will depend less on whether one or two sectors continue to outperform and more on whether the expansion generates a wider base of purchasing power, employment and productive investment.

A 7.5% growth rate would be an impressive achievement in an uncertain global environment. But the quality of that growth matters as much as its headline magnitude. An economy in which manufacturing and financial services expand while agricultural incomes weaken, employment-intensive services lose momentum and household budgets come under inflationary pressure cannot indefinitely rely on aggregate GDP figures as evidence of economic strength.

The next phase of India’s growth story will require more than maintaining production momentum. It will require restoring rural purchasing power, protecting household consumption without fuelling inflation, sustaining productive public investment and creating conditions in which private capital can expand beyond a limited group of industries.

The second-quarter numbers may establish that India remains a fast-growing major economy. Whether it can preserve that position will depend on its ability to convert sectoral strength into broad-based economic resilience.